Back Story: Sometimes I click the "next blog" button at the top of the screen just to see the random assortment of things that are out there in the blogosphere. My favorites are the ones in foreign languages, where I have to figure out who it's by and what's going on without benefit of understanding the words. My least favorites are usually the ones by American women, moms specifically, as they tend to get more cutesy than I can handle. (Yes, I do have a blog about my daughter, and, yes, I appreciate the irony of that last statement.) I stumbled on to one of those blogs that makes me cringe today, and since it pushed a holiday hot button for me, I'm gonna tell you all about it.
Let me walk you through it...
The blog was by a mom of two little girls. Most of the blog was about the mom's rabid pursuit of the perfect scrapbook page and included pictures of her pages in progress and links to the sites of her other crafty-type mom friends.
Today's entry, though, was a picture of her two daughters, who looked like they were about three and five years old, sitting on the lap of a mall Santa.
They were both screaming. Full-on, eyes wide in terror, get-me-out-of-here screaming. The mom's comment below the picture was How adorable. No winking emoticon to convey sarcasm in her message. No story of how long they'd waited in line, which one started crying first or explanation as to why. In short, no context. Just a picture of two very unhappy-looking girls sitting on a weirdly-calm mall Santa's lap and the words How adorable.
A couple of her crafty-type mom friends had chimed in with comments, all of which included the words cute and hilarious.
Why do people do this?
I don't even know these girls, but my heart went out to them immediately. Going to meet Santa is supposed to be fun.
Yes, fun.
For the kids.
It's for them, not so that Mom and Dad can get a picture to put in the scrapbook.
So why do people keep their kids in line or go ahead with the picture if the kid's obviously not having any fun?
Last year, my parents took my then one year-old daughter to the mall, and my dad got in line with her to meet Santa. Another child in front of them started crying and saying, "No!" My daughter looked at Grandpa and shook her head to say, "I don't think I like this." Grandpa listened and said they'd try it again another time. Yes, my dad listened to my daughter and respected her wishes. And that's just the sort of thing I love him for.
Sure, sometimes kids say, "No!" to stuff (like holding your hand when you're crossing the street) that you just have to insist they follow through with for their own safety. Sometimes I go a few rounds with my daughter about her needing to put on her pj's, wear shoes outside, or wash her hands before dinner. I don't back down because those are instances where she's testing the boundaries of her authority to self-govern, as it were.
Going to visit Santa is a whole 'nother ball game, though.
You can't force a kid to have fun.
And it's neither cute nor hilarious when people try to.
4 comments:
It took Sean 5 years before he would sit on Santa's lap. That was the only time we did that and somehow my children have grown up quite adjusted. I think this woman is horrid and her children will one day grow up and probable hate Santa. Afterall Santa is awfully close to Satan. Just a litle jumble of the letters.
December 22, 2008 at 6:13 PMHappy Holidays,
MCQ
I'm sure it'll work out with the woman and her kids... McQ's post is clearly retarded. just a jumble of the letters!
December 23, 2008 at 1:11 PMThis is for Chad and his $.02. Oh I know you did not call me retarded. That would just be so not true.
December 24, 2008 at 12:06 AMActually I really enjoy your posts and am beginning to understand your humor. "He he he Yoda." (I do know a few things about you.):)
McQ
My concern was not so much for the kids' future attitudes toward Santa (or that he is demon-spawn), but that this mom was teaching her kids that their feelings didn't matter and that they don't have the power to say NO to an adult, even when something makes them uncomfortable.
December 24, 2008 at 11:21 AMI've seen WAY too many Oprah shows where they talk about victims of crimes who felt in their gut that something was wrong but didn't get themselves out of a situation because they didn't want to appear rude.
As a culture, we undervalue the importance of our instincts and gut-feelings. Making your kids sit on a stranger's lap, even though they're screaming that they don't want to, just strikes me as one way of training them to stop listening to that voice inside.
Post a Comment